join e newsJoin the e-newsletter   Search site | Contact me    
 
 
Access Card Survey

Our constant work to highlight the privacy and security concerns of the access card saw it temporarily stopped in its tracks in 2007, and the Labor Party has now committed to dumping it altogether – at least in its current form.

This was a key campaign issue for my office during 2007, stepping up when the first raft of legislation was introduced in February, and during the subsequent Senate committee inquiry which we fought to secure. The legislation was postponed following the Government-chaired Senate committee’s damning report, but my office kept up the campaign against it, launching a ‘No ID’ campaign through my website which included a petition; mock ID card; flyer; poster, and community survey.

Parliamentary work included a motion calling on the Government to release the full KPMG report and privacy impact assessment on the card; and numerous questions on notice about the Card through the Senate and estimates.

Our community survey results indicate that 73% of respondents were outright against the card, 79% believed that it will morph into an I.D. card and 77% were concerned that the card would lead to an invasion of privacy. Full results of the survey are set out below.

Meanwhile, Finance Minister, Lindsay Tanner, confirmed within a week of the 2007 election that the Access Card will be scrapped, based on projected costs savings of over $1 billion. The project stood to create the largest mass centralisation of personal data in Australia’s history. While its dumping is warmly welcomed, the cost justification that belies the Labor Government’s decision reflects a reluctance to commit to its abolition on principled grounds. Indeed, it was the ALP that attempted to introduce the Australia Card in the 1980s and one wonders whether a cheaper alternative will not rear itself at some stage during the Government’s term.

I will continue to keep the Government accountable on issues of privacy for the remainder of my term, including by keeping a close watch on how the Rudd Government plans to salvage the extraordinary amount of money put into the Access Card proposal.
 
 

Question

Yes

No

Unsure

Will the card reduce Commonwealth Fraud?

62

135

41

 

26%

57%

17%

Will the Access Card save taxpayer Dollars?

34

166

29

 

15%

72%

13%

Should there be a photo on surface?

99

129

19

 

40%

52%

8%

Should it have an Electronic Signature?

74

125

36

 

31%

53%

15%

Are you concerned the card will be refused?

50

152

39

 

21%

63%

16%

Can the Dep. Of Human Services keep info secure?

37

174

28

 

15%

73%

12%

Are you concerned the card will lead to invasion of privacy?

175

39

13

 

77%

17%

6%

Are you concerned about false enrolment?

169

60

13

 

70%

25%

5%

Are you concerned about false identity verification?

176

50

10

 

75%

21%

4%

Are you concerned it could become national identification card?

187

39

11

 

79%

16%

5%

Should the Card be used for other transactions?

35

180

18

 

15%

77%

8%

Are you For or Against the Access Card?

For

Against

Unsure

 

38

164

24

 

17%

73%

11%

 
More information about the Access Card proposal is available at: (STOP THE ACCESS CARD NOW!), among other sources.

Print this page

Access Card Effectiveness

Do you think the Access Card will reduce Commonwealth fraud?
  Yes No Unsure
     
Do you think the Access Card will save taxpayer dollars?   Yes No Unsure
     

Access Card Concerns

   
Should the Access Card contain a photograph on the surface of the Card?   Yes No Unsure
     
Should the Access Card contain an electronic signature on the Card?   Yes No Unsure
     
Are you concerned that the Access Card system might refuse you a Card ?   Yes No Unsure
     
Do you think the Department of Human Services can keep personal information secure?   Yes No Unsure
     

Are you concerned about the Access Card leading to an invasion of your privacy?
Too much information about you on file or Commonwealth employees snooping on your file
 

  Yes No Unsure
     

Data Accuracy

Are you concerned about false enrolment?
Someone else obtains your details and enrols as you for an Access Card

  Yes No Unsure
     

Are you concerned about false identity verification?
System says you’re not who you claim to be, or an Government employee say’s your someone else

  Yes No Unsure
     

Access Card Uses

   

Are you concerned  that the Access Card could become a national identification card?

  Yes No Unsure
     

Should the Access Card be used for transactions other than for welfare and health administration?

  Yes No Unsure
     

Conclusion

   
Are you for or against the Access Card?   For Against Unsure
     

Impersonal Details

   
Are you male or female?   Male Female
     
Please choose your age group  
     
Do you have any other comments?  
   
 
   212 Grenfell Street, Adelaide SA 5000   |   T: (08) 8232 7595